Finances
What to Pay a First Part-Time Staff Hire at 70 People
100 Strong · November 2, 2026
Photo by Thilina Alagiyawanna on Unsplash
You are sitting at roughly 70 people on a Sunday, and the work has outgrown what you and a few volunteers can carry. Maybe it is a worship leader, a part-time administrator, or someone to run kids ministry. The desire is good. But the question underneath keeps you up at night: can we actually afford to pay someone, and how much is honest to offer?
This is one of the most tender moments in a small church's financial life. Get it right and you free yourself to lead. Get it wrong and you strain the budget, erode trust, or set up a good person to fail. Let's walk through the math together, slowly and honestly.
Start with the napkin math
Before you name a salary, locate yourself financially. The most useful rule a small-church pastor owns is roughly $20 per attender per week, counting kids. At 70 people, that points to somewhere near $70,000 to $75,000 a year in income if your giving culture is healthy. The median for a church in the 51 to 100 band is about $150,000, so there is a real range here depending on how long your people have been discipled toward generosity.
If your actual income trails the rule of thumb badly, the hire is not your first problem. The giving culture is. That is a discipleship issue, not a poverty issue, and it belongs upstream of this decision.
Know where your money already goes
Here is the reality that makes a part-time hire hard: across congregations, staff already eats about 44% of the budget and buildings about 26% before a single dollar reaches ministry. That leaves roughly 11% for program and 13% for mission.
At 70 people, you are likely the only paid person, so your staff line has margin a larger church does not. But you still need to protect against buildings or an over-sized salary crowding out ministry. A part-time hire should fit inside your existing staff percentage without pushing the whole split out of balance. If adding this person drives staff well past 44% of total income, you are hiring ahead of your resources.
Size the pay to what you can actually carry
Full-time becomes realistically viable around 80 to 90 adults and about $30,000-plus in income. At 70, you are below that line, which is exactly why part-time is the wise call. Resist the pull to pay a full-time salary for part-time hours just because you like the person.
A few honest principles:
- Pay for a defined number of hours, not a vague role. Ten or fifteen hours a week with clear expectations is far healthier than "whatever it takes."
- Build margin on purpose. Your operating budget should raise income, set goals, and limit expenses so the new line does not consume every spare dollar. If the hire leaves you with zero cushion, it is too big.
- Do not deplete your reserve to do it. You are aiming to hold two to three months of operating expenses in reserve as a buffer for giving dips and transitions. A new salary should not be funded by spending down that cushion.
Remember the frugality principle of new work: the resources are in the harvest. Do not commit the church to a salary it cannot yet carry. It is better to start small and increase hours as attendance and giving grow than to over-promise and claw back.
Create your free 100 Strong account to turn ideas like these into a clear plan. Track your weekly numbers, get a personalized next step, and walk the proven path to 100+ members. No cost, ever.
Create my free accountSet the compensation up correctly from day one
The day you pay anyone, do it right. A messy setup is one of the fastest ways to damage trust, and nothing erodes a small church's credibility like the appearance of financial mismanagement.
- Classify the person as an employee, not a contractor, unless a church-savvy CPA tells you otherwise.
- If your hire is an ordained minister, your board can designate part of their pay as a tax-excluded housing allowance. This must be board-designated in advance and in writing, used for housing, and capped at fair rental value.
- Budget for self-employment tax. Ministers pay the full 15.3%, not a split. Factor that into what you offer so the real cost is on the table.
Consult a church-savvy CPA for the setup. It is worth the one-time cost.
Protect the person and the church with controls
Adding a paid staff member is the right moment to firm up your financial controls, because now more hands are near the money. The goal is simple: no single person has unchecked access to funds.
- Dual signatures on checks over a threshold (a common example is $500 to $1,000).
- Monthly bank-statement review by someone other than the bookkeeper.
- Board approval over a set threshold.
- Two unrelated people counting offerings together, signing a count sheet, and depositing within a day or two.
Controls are not about suspicion. They protect the church from loss and protect your new staff member from ever being wrongly accused.
Map the path, not just the moment
Tie future pay increases to attendance milestones, not hope. Sketch a path from part-time toward more hours and eventually full-time as you cross 80 to 90 adults and your income supports it. Linking the raise to real growth keeps everyone honest and keeps the budget sound.
What to do next
Name the role and the hours first, then run your ~$20/head/week number, check that the new salary fits inside a healthy expense split, confirm your reserve stays intact, and set up compensation and controls correctly before the first paycheck. Do it in that order and your first hire becomes a blessing rather than a burden.
Your challenge this week
Sit down with one sheet of paper and write three numbers: your average attendance (kids included) times $20 times 52 for projected annual income, your current total expenses, and the dollar amount left as margin. If there is not at least a few months of reserve plus room for the new salary, adjust the hours before you adjust anything else.
